Key facts
- Deadline to sue (vehicle crash)
- 3 yearsIn Colorado you generally have 3 years from the date of a car, truck or motorcycle crash to file an injury lawsuit.C.R.S. § 13-80-101(1)(n)
- Deadline to sue (most other injuries)
- 2 yearsMost other injury claims, like slip and falls, premises cases and dog bites, must be filed within 2 years.C.R.S. § 13-80-102(1)(a)
Why might you reject an insurance settlement offer?
Usually because the offer does not cover what you lost. Insurers pay claims from their own money, so first offers are often low. Common problems include:
- Only early bills are counted. Ongoing care, therapy and lost pay may be left out.
- Pain and suffering is ignored. These are real losses under Colorado law.
- Fault is disputed. The insurer may deny its driver was to blame and offer a small amount to close the file.
- The offer comes too soon. Offers made before treatment ends can miss costs you do not know about yet.
If you are unsure, a lawyer can compare the offer to your actual losses.
What happens after you reject the offer?
Nothing closes automatically. The next step is usually more negotiation. If you have not already hired a lawyer, many people do at this point. Your lawyer may send a demand letter, which lays out your losses and why the other side is responsible. See our page on demand letters.
From there, one of two things usually happens.
Do negotiations continue after you say no?
Often, yes. Your counteroffer should explain each part of your losses and what it is worth. The stronger your evidence, the harder it is for the insurer to ignore: medical records, estimates of future care, photos, witness statements and repair estimates.
Some cases move to mediation, where a neutral person helps both sides talk. When the insurer sees a well-supported claim, it may be more willing to settle for a fair amount.
Does rejecting an offer mean going to court?
Not always, but it can. If talks stall, your lawyer may file a lawsuit. Filing does not mean a trial is certain. Many filed cases still settle after both sides exchange evidence. See why a case goes to trial.
If the insurer is acting unfairly, such as dragging its feet or refusing to explain a denial, that can raise separate issues. A lawyer can tell you whether yours fit.
Does the deadline to sue keep running?
Yes, and insurers know it. You usually have 3 years to sue after a vehicle crash (C.R.S. § 13-80-101(1)(n)). Most other injury claims, like slip and falls, premises cases and dog bites, must be filed within 2 years.
Endless back-and-forth can run out the clock. Rejecting an offer is fine, but track the date.
What should you do before you reject an offer?
Get the facts in order first. Write down what the offer covers and what it leaves out. Gather your bills, your pay records and your doctor’s notes on future care. Ask your doctor whether your treatment is finished. Offers made while treatment is still ongoing often miss costs that have not happened yet.
Then compare the offer to what you have actually lost. A lawyer can help with that, and can explain how the insurer likely reached its number.
How do you decide whether to reject an offer?
Ask two questions.
- Does the offer cover everything you have lost and are likely to lose, including future care?
- Will you be paying out of pocket later if you accept?
A lawyer can answer the first and help with the second. Once you accept and sign a release, the claim is usually closed. Talk to us for a free case review before you decide.
Related questions
Can I change my mind after rejecting an offer?
Often, yes. The insurer may keep the offer open, lower it, or withdraw it, so do not assume it will return.
Will the insurer raise its offer?
Sometimes. A well-documented counteroffer that lays out your bills, lost pay and future care gives the adjuster reasons to move.
Do I have to go to trial if I reject an offer?
No. Most cases that are filed still settle before trial. A trial happens only when the case cannot be resolved.
What if I already accepted an offer?
Usually the claim is closed once you sign a release, even if new bills show up. Get advice before you sign.
