Key facts
- Fault rule
- Modified comparative fault (under 50%)You can recover if you were less than 50% at fault. Your award is reduced by your share of fault. At 50% or more, you recover nothing.C.R.S. § 13-21-111
- Deadline to sue (vehicle crash)
- 3 yearsIn Colorado you generally have 3 years from the date of a car, truck or motorcycle crash to file an injury lawsuit.C.R.S. § 13-80-101(1)(n)
What does it mean to lose a personal injury claim?
Losing usually means the case ends without any payment to you. That can happen at trial, but it can also happen long before one.
A claim can fail because the evidence did not show the other side was at fault. It can fail because fault was disputed and you could not prove your version. Or it can stall because you missed a deadline. In Colorado you usually have 3 years to sue after a vehicle crash (C.R.S. § 13-80-101(1)(n)).
Fault also decides the outcome. Colorado’s rule says you can recover if you were less than 50% at fault, and your award is reduced by your share of blame. At 50% or more, you recover nothing.
Do you still pay legal fees if you lose?
It depends on your fee agreement, but many injury lawyers are paid only if there is a recovery. If the case brings in nothing, you typically owe no attorney’s fee.
Costs are a separate question. Things like medical records, filing fees and expert witnesses can add up. A clear agreement says whether those costs come out of a recovery, and what happens to them if there is none. Ask before you sign. You can read how we handle fees on our fees page.
What happens to your medical bills?
You are still responsible for them. A lost claim does not erase the bills.
Some help may exist:
- Your health insurance may pay part of your treatment, depending on your plan.
- Your own auto policy may include medical payments coverage, which can pay regardless of fault.
- Some providers agree to wait for payment until a case ends. If there is no recovery, they may still expect to be paid, but many will talk about a payment plan or a lower balance.
If a provider holds a lien, see what a lien is and how medical bills are handled.
Can you appeal or reopen a claim after losing?
Sometimes, but the options are narrow. An appeal asks a higher court to find a legal mistake, such as a wrong rule applied or key evidence wrongly kept out. It is not a chance to retell the story.
New evidence alone rarely reopens a closed case. The details depend on how the claim ended: a denied insurance claim, a settlement, a verdict. Talk to a lawyer before you decide. Our page on reopening a case explains more.
What can you do after a claim fails?
Start with the money, then the paperwork.
- Call your providers and ask about payment plans.
- Review every policy you have for benefits you have not used.
- Ask a second lawyer to look at the file. Sometimes a denied claim still has a path, and sometimes it does not. Either answer helps you plan.
How can you lower the risk of losing?
No one can promise an outcome, but some habits make a claim stronger.
- Get medical care promptly and follow the plan, so your records link your injuries to the event.
- Keep bills, pay stubs and notes on how the injury affects your day.
- Be careful with insurance adjusters, and do not post about the incident online.
- Get legal advice early, before deadlines get close.
If you are unsure where your claim stands, talk to us for a free case review.
Related questions
Do I owe my lawyer anything if I lose?
It depends on your fee agreement. Many injury lawyers are paid only from a recovery, but the agreement should say who pays case costs if there is none. Read that part before you sign.
Can I try again if my claim is denied?
Often yes, if the deadline to sue has not passed, and an insurer's denial is not a court ruling. After a court judgment, your options are narrow.
Do I still have to pay my medical bills?
Yes. Health insurance or medical payments coverage may pay part of them. A provider that agreed to wait for a settlement may still expect payment if there is none.
Can I appeal a verdict against me?
Sometimes. An appeal argues the court made a legal error. It is not a second chance to retry the facts.
