Free case review · 24/7(888) 754-9272

Will a pre-existing injury affect my personal injury claim?

It can, but it does not automatically end your claim. If an accident made an old injury or condition worse, you may be able to seek compensation for the worsening. Insurers look closely at these claims, so be honest about your history and keep medical records from before and after the accident.

Key facts

Fault rule
Modified comparative fault (under 50%)You can recover if you were less than 50% at fault. Your award is reduced by your share of fault. At 50% or more, you recover nothing.C.R.S. § 13-21-111

What counts as a pre-existing condition?

Any injury, illness or physical condition you had before the accident. Examples include old back or neck injuries, arthritis, a prior surgery, or a chronic condition. Many people have something in their medical history, and having one does not shut the door on a claim.

Can I still make a claim?

Often yes, if the accident caused new harm or made the old problem worse. The claim is not for the old injury itself. It is for the part that the accident caused or made worse: new symptoms, more treatment, more pain, or time off work. Whether and how much you can recover depends on the facts and the medical evidence.

How do insurers treat pre-existing conditions?

With extra suspicion. Adjusters often argue that your pain comes from the old condition, not the accident. They may ask for years of medical records and look for earlier complaints in your history. This does not mean your claim is weak. It means the records matter.

Why should I be honest about my history?

Because it will usually come out, and hiding it can damage your credibility. Insurers can request medical records and ask you about prior injuries. If you leave something out and they find it, they may argue everything you said is unreliable. Tell your lawyer and your doctors the whole story, including old problems that seem minor.

What evidence helps?

  • Records from before the accident. They show what your condition was like then.
  • Records from after the accident. They show new symptoms, new diagnoses and a change in treatment.
  • Your doctor’s opinion. A treating doctor may be able to explain how the accident changed your condition. Some cases also use an independent medical professional.
  • Imaging. Before-and-after scans can show changes.
  • Your own notes and statements from people who know you. They can describe what you could do before and what you cannot do now.

What if I had no treatment before the accident?

That can help show the accident changed things. If you had a condition but were not getting care or missing work, and then you needed treatment after the crash, that contrast is useful. Medical records still matter, so see a doctor soon after the accident.

How does shared fault fit in?

It is separate, but both can come up in the same claim. Colorado lets you recover if you were less than 50% at fault, with your award reduced by your share of fault. A pre-existing condition is a different question: what did the accident cause. Insurers may argue both at once.

How can I protect my claim?

  • Get medical care soon after the accident, and follow your treatment plan.
  • Tell every provider about your history.
  • Keep records and bills organized.
  • Do not guess about your old condition when talking to an adjuster.
  • Stay off social media about your activities.

Our blog explains more about claims with a pre-existing condition and how car accidents can aggravate existing conditions. Talk to us for a free case review.

Related questions

Should I tell the insurer about my old injury?

Be truthful if you are asked, and tell your lawyer everything. Hiding a prior injury can hurt your credibility if it comes out later.

What if my old injury never gave me trouble before?

That can help. Records and statements showing you were doing fine before the accident support the idea that the crash made things worse.

Can an insurer deny my claim because of an old injury?

They may try. The question is whether the accident caused new harm or made an old problem worse, and the records can show that.

No fee
unless we win.*

Only pay if we win. Contact us 24/7.

Our team is available 24/7Talk to a real person

Click to start your free consultation

Call (888) 754-9272
Michael Zara