Key facts
- Fault rule
- Modified comparative fault (under 50%)You can recover if you were less than 50% at fault. Your award is reduced by your share of fault. At 50% or more, you recover nothing.C.R.S. § 13-21-111
What counts as a pre-existing condition?
Any injury or health condition you had before the accident. It might come from an earlier accident, a disease or an illness. Common ones in injury claims include:
- A back injury
- Neck or spine injuries
- A past traumatic brain injury
- Mental health conditions
- Arthritis
- Bone conditions
- Other illnesses
Accidents add stress to the body. Any of these can get worse, and they can make your current claim harder to prove.
Can you still make a claim?
Yes. You can still pursue the person who caused your injury. Under the “eggshell skull” idea, a person who causes an injury is responsible for the harm even if they did not know you were more fragile than most. They take you as they find you. That does not mean every symptom is blamed on the accident. It means the real harm the accident caused can be part of your claim.
How do you separate the old injury from the new harm?
With your medical history and doctors’ opinions. It can be hard to tell where the old condition ends and the accident’s effect begins. You must show how your condition got worse after the crash. That starts with:
- Records of your condition before the accident.
- The exam right after it.
- Follow-up care and new treatment.
- A doctor’s explanation of the added harm.
Your lawyer pulls together records and testimony so the claim is not dismissed unfairly.
Why do pre-existing conditions make claims harder?
Insurers use them to lower what they pay.
- They may say your symptoms are the normal progress of your condition, not the accident.
- They may argue you were already in pain or already had limits.
- It is hard to show what the other party caused and what they did not.
Medical records and testimony help, but these cases need careful investigation and steady negotiation.
What can you recover?
The harm the accident caused, not the original condition. Depending on the facts, a claim can include:
- Medical bills for the added treatment
- Lost wages
- Property damage
- Pain and suffering
Because of the difficulty of separating the two, a clear medical story matters even more.
How does fault fit in?
Fault works the same as in any claim. In Colorado you can still recover if you were less than 50% at fault, with your award reduced by your share of fault (C.R.S. § 13-21-111). Insurers sometimes use an old condition and fault together to argue down a claim.
How can you protect your claim?
Be honest, get care and keep records.
- See a doctor soon after the accident and describe your history.
- Follow your treatment plan.
- Keep all records, bills and notes on symptoms.
- Do not minimize or hide your prior condition.
- Talk to a lawyer before you speak with the insurer.
How can we help?
We can talk to the insurer, collect the records and make the case for fair value. A pre-existing condition is something insurers expect. It is not the end of a claim. Talk to us for a free case review.
Related questions
Will a pre-existing condition reduce my settlement?
It can affect how the insurer values the claim. The goal is to show what the accident added, with records and a doctor's explanation.
Should I tell the insurer about my old condition?
Be honest. Hiding a prior condition can hurt your credibility. Talk to a lawyer before giving any statement.
Can I recover for the old condition itself?
Generally no. A claim looks at the new harm or the worsening the accident caused.
What records matter most?
Your medical history, the first exam after the accident and follow-up care. Together they show the change.
