Free case review · 24/7(888) 754-9272

When does a car accident go to court?

A car accident usually goes to court when settlement talks fail, because the insurer disputes fault, offers too little, or the policy limits are too low. Filing a lawsuit does not mean a trial is certain. Many filed cases still settle. In Colorado you usually have 3 years to file after a vehicle crash.

Updated

Key facts

Deadline to sue (vehicle crash)
3 yearsIn Colorado you generally have 3 years from the date of a car, truck or motorcycle crash to file an injury lawsuit.C.R.S. § 13-80-101(1)(n)
Fault rule
Modified comparative fault (under 50%)You can recover if you were less than 50% at fault. Your award is reduced by your share of fault. At 50% or more, you recover nothing.C.R.S. § 13-21-111

Why does a car accident go to court?

Because the claim could not be settled. Most start as an insurance claim against the other driver’s insurer. You share what happened and what it cost you. If the insurer agrees to a fair amount, that is the end of it.

Insurers do not always do that. They may delay, blame you, or make a low offer. A lawyer can negotiate for you, but if that fails, a lawsuit is the next step.

What are the common reasons for filing a lawsuit?

Three come up most.

  • The offer is too low. The insurer undervalues your injuries, future care or lost income.
  • Fault is disputed. The insurer says its driver was not to blame, or that you were. Colorado lets you recover if you were less than 50% at fault, with your award reduced by your share (C.R.S. § 13-21-111).
  • Insurance is not enough. The other driver’s policy cannot cover your losses.

Another reason is time. In Colorado you usually have 3 years to file (C.R.S. § 13-80-101(1)(n)). If you are near the end, a lawsuit may be needed to protect your claim.

What happens after a lawsuit is filed?

The case moves through a few stages.

  1. Filing. Your lawyer files a complaint in the proper court.
  2. Discovery. Both sides exchange records and evidence, such as medical records, bills, police reports and video. Witnesses may be questioned under oath.
  3. Settlement talks. After discovery, both sides often try again to settle, sometimes through mediation.
  4. Trial, if the case does not settle.

Our page on litigation explains the terms.

What happens at trial?

Both sides present their case, and a judge or jury decides. Each lawyer gives an opening statement, presents evidence and questions witnesses. Closing arguments follow. Then the jury deliberates, or the judge decides in a bench trial.

If you win, the other side may be ordered to pay damages. If the result goes against you, an appeal may be possible in limited cases, but only if there was a legal error. See what happens if you lose.

What can you recover in a court case?

The same kinds of losses as in a settlement. The amount depends on your injuries, the evidence and any share of fault.

  • Medical expenses, including ongoing care and equipment
  • Lost wages
  • Property damage
  • Pain and suffering
  • Emotional distress
  • Reduced quality of life and loss of enjoyment
  • Loss of companionship (consortium), in some cases

No lawyer can promise a result. Any amount in the claim may change by trial.

How do you know your case is headed to court?

Usually the signs build over time. The insurer stops moving on its offer, denies that its driver was at fault, or stops responding. Your lawyer then tells you the next step is a lawsuit, and explains the cost, the timeline and the risks.

It is your decision. A good lawyer will lay out the choice: take the offer, keep negotiating, or file. Filing does not close the door on settling later.

Do most car accident cases go to trial?

No. Most are settled before trial. Filing a lawsuit often puts pressure on the insurer, and many cases resolve once evidence has been exchanged. Our related questions below explain more.

If you are unsure whether your case is headed for court, talk to us for a free case review.

Related questions

Do most car accident cases go to trial?

No. Most settle before trial, often after both sides see the evidence.

Read the full answer

What is discovery?

It is the stage where both sides share records and evidence and may question witnesses under oath.

Can I settle after I file a lawsuit?

Yes. Cases can settle at any point, including during or after mediation, or even during trial.

How long does a lawsuit take?

It depends on the court schedule and the case. A lawsuit often adds months or more to the timeline.

Read the full answer

Sources

No fee
unless we win.*

Only pay if we win. Contact us 24/7.

Our team is available 24/7Talk to a real person

Click to start your free consultation

Call (888) 754-9272
Michael Zara